STRENGTH
TRAINING FOR OSTEOPOROSIS PREVENTION
By Jessica Faller-Berger
If
you have been diagnosed with Osteopenia, there are ways
to avoid a later diagnosis of Osteoporosis. Osteopenia
is a condition characterized by “a diminished amount
of bone tissue” (Taber's Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary).
Osteoporosis primarily affects women and is the leading
cause of pathological bone fractures. According to Monahan,
Drake and Neighbors, osteopenia is normal bone loss associated
with aging, with “peak bone mass occurring at age
35”. Risk factors for Osteoporosis include inactivity,
anorexia, calcium deficiency, amenorrhea, and postmenopausal
status. We may unwittingly invite Osteoporosis by dutifully
taking our medications such as “tetracyclines, corticosteroids,
aluminum containing antacids, anticonvulsants (seizure
medications), diuretics (water pills), and thyroid medications”
(Monahan etal). Monahan, Drake and Neighbors further describe
secondary osteoporosis as the result of hyperthyroidism
and Cushing’s Disease. A diagnosis of Osteopenia
can be an awakening for the sedentary: immediate action
will be required to prevent Osteoporosis.
There are ways to counter the effects of the aforementioned
osteoporosis risk factors. According to Paul Sorace, M.S.,
RCEP (sm), CCS, Clinical Exercise Physiologist, “A
complete exercise program, along with a proper diet, can
prevent Osteopenia from becoming osteoporosis. The goal
of the exercise program should be to increase bone density
and improve balance to promote fall prevention.”
For pre-menopausal women, a bone healthy diet includes
1000 mg of calcium per day, as recommended by the National
Institutes of Health (Personal Trainer Manual,
American Council on Exercise, 1996). The NIH adds that
in the absence of estrogen therapy, calcium intake for
postmenopausal women is 1500 mg/day. Strikingly, the Health
and Nutrition Examination Survey found that “50
percent of all females age 15 and older consume less than
75% of the RDA of calcium”. According to Essentials
of Nutrition and Diet Therapy author Sue Williams,
calcium rich foods include yogurt (355 mg per 8 ounces),
skim milk (302 mg calcium per 8 ounces), figs (269 mg
calcium per 10 figs), almonds (148mg per 1 ounce), and
collards (148 mg per 1 cup).
Offering an alternative perspective on calcium intake,
the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals web site
quotes a study from Harvard University in which 78,000
American women were followed for 12 years. PETA reports
that Harvard researchers discovered “it is unlikely
that high consumption of milk or other food sources of
calcium during midlife will confer substantial protective
effects against hip or forearm fractures”. This
opposing viewpoint is emblematic of the lack of uniformity
in many arenas of osteoporosis prevention research.
One thing is certain. The improvement of balance should
be a major component in any Osteoporosis Prevention Program.
Medline stresses the benefits of Tai chi and Yoga. Aerobics
and Dance also cultivate balance, while furnishing excellent
cardiovascular gains. People with Osteopenia should enjoy
continuous aerobic activity three times a week for 20-30
minutes. Your exercise intensity should feel "somewhat
hard". If you can’t chat with a friend while
training, ease up until you could pass the talk-test.
Should people with Osteopenia use exercise machines for
weight training? The American College of Sports Medicine
explains that “it is difficult to increase bone
mineral density of the hip using traditional weight machines
in a seated position. This is because the forces at the
hip will be reduced. It is better to use free weights
or machines that require standing.” ACSM encourages
the introduction of hand-held free weights to traditional
lunges and squats for bone remodeling, balance, and coordination.
Once you have gained proficiency, ACSM suggests wearing
a weighted vest to increase intensity and further improve
bone mineral density.
For optimal bone remodeling, it’s preferable to
lift a heavier weight fewer times than to lift a lighter
weight many times. This is because “mechanical force
magnitude is more important than the number of repetitions”
(ACSM, Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription).
However, when beginning a weight lifting routine, it is
safest to work with a qualified professional. For the
neophyte weightlifter, the inadvertent choice of a too-heavy
weight can compromise the joints. Joint injury can sabotage
your weight lifting routine, which in turn can lead to
further bone demineralization.
Attention people with Osteopenia: don’t do “The
Twist”, especially while holding weights. Other
taboo exercises for the Osteopenic or Osteoporotic Crowd
include crunches and typical sit-ups. These movements
involve spinal flexion and “increase the likelihood
of compression wedge fractures in the lumbar spine”
(Paul Sorace, Clinical Exercise Physiologist). Those with
Osteopenia should never pull on the neck. Instead, focus
on exercises that stabilize the core while keeping the
spine straight.
Osteopenic bones will be protected by weight lifting and
impact exercise only as long as the exercise program regularly
continues. You can not "save-up" the benefits
of exercise. Training for a long time one or two days
a month confers dubious benefit. Such a training schedule
is akin to brushing your teeth for two hours on Sunday
so you won’t have to brush them all next week. It
just doesn’t work. This metaphor describes the reversibility
principle of exercise, which states “In the adult
skeleton, when the loading (weightlifting) is removed,
the positive effect on bone is lost” (page 302,
IBID). If you've been handed the word "osteopenia"
to describe your bones, take the proactive approach. After
a year of lifestyle changes including weight training,
aerobic activity, and improved diet, you could request
a bone mineral density test to assess your new improved
status. Just remember that "An increase in bone mass of
more than one percent over nine months is significant
because the average rate of loss is 0.5-1% per year."
(ACSM, Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription).
Are Dumbbells for Dumbbells? Does weightlifting make you
DENSE? Yes it does! And just where you want to be dense...
in your bones.
|